Since the advent of radio and television broadcasting in New Zealand there has been a general assumption, supported by successive governments over the last ninety years, that there is an important social value in maintaining publicly owned radio and television services. The perceived worth of public broadcasting has been something many New Zealanders have long supported and enjoyed.
However,
public broadcasting is now facing arguably its most severe crisis, and there
are no guarantees about its future. Questions are being raised about whether it
has any future at all, and whether now is the time to sell-off Television New
Zealand and Radio New Zealand. Currently, both Television New Zealand and Radio
New Zealand are struggling, highlighted by protests by staff of both organisations
this week, concerned about their futures.
The
dramatic revelations about Radio New Zealand’s massive, twenty-five times
larger than forecast budget blowout of almost $12 million has raised
fundamental questions about not only the competence of the oversight provided
by its Board, but even more serious and immediate questions about whether the
organisation can survive this crisis. The Prime Minister has already ruled out
any bailout by the current government, and no other parties seem to be rushing to
Radio New Zealand’s aid.
In
the short term, significant job cuts seem inevitable. The impact of these on Radio
New Zealand’s programming is likely to be severe, strongly affecting its
ability to attract and retain its listening audience. At the same time, it is
not at all clear these moves alone will be sufficient to restore the
organisation’s long-term financial viability.
As
a free-to-air terrestrial broadcaster Television New Zealand is facing its own significant
challenges from innovative and more flexible on-line streaming platforms and
subscriber services. While Television New Zealand does run some satellite
services and its own streaming and on-demand services, its traditional audience
share for terrestrial services is diminishing and advertising revenues are
declining.
Television
New Zealand is owned by the government and is structured as a stand-alone commercial
company. However, because it is expected to stand on its own feet there is
little current indication there will be any significant future additional
capital injections from the government. Moreover, Television New Zealand will
always struggle in the face of significantly larger competing overseas media
companies. Hence the current round of staff cuts that are currently being
considered, principally in the news area.
Overall,
it seems likely that neither Radio New Zealand nor Television New Zealand will
survive in their current forms. That is why some, like the ACT Party, are
arguing this is now the time for the government to cut its losses and sell-off
both organisations. But that is too extreme a solution. Aside from anything else
that might achieve, it would surely spell, without debate, the end of public
broadcasting in New Zealand, a move that would be unacceptable to many.
A
more prudent solution might be to return to the roots of public broadcasting in
New Zealand and re-establish an integrated publicly owned national broadcasting
service with its own independent Board. In essence, the model would not be
dissimilar to the structure of the old NZBC, before it became so politically
compromised by its timid and too craven editorial approach in the 1960s.
A
combined radio and television news service could be re-established, with common
newsrooms and staff shared between radio and television. Similar arrangements could
be entered into regarding wider programming, with a joint production capability
competing strongly for funding from New Zealand On-air for specific funding, although
more commercially focused programme making could be privatised.
To
prevent the new entity becoming the government of the day’s plaything the way
the old NZBC did in the 1960s and early 1970s, the Charter currently governing
Radio New Zealand could be strengthened and applied to television as well. This
would restore the situation that prevailed until 2011 when the government
deemed the Charter requirements were inconsistent with Television New Zealand’s
statutory requirement to operate as a stand-alone commercial company.
Overall,
a new structure along these lines would be much trimmer than the current
broadcasting organisations, but far more sharply focused, with an overriding
emphasis on public broadcasting services, without the current commercial
overlay. Funding from the government could then be tailored to focus on the delivery
of those services across the country.
Whatever
happens from here, the future of public radio and television services is in for
a major shake-up, regardless of which collection of parties forms the next
government. Recent events affecting both Television New Zealand and Radio New
Zealand have starkly shown the unsustainability of both the current models. But
as these inevitable changes occur, ensuring the retention of a quality public broadcasting
will be of critical importance.
Therefore,
now, more than ever before, the voices of those advocating for such need to be
heard.
No comments:
Post a Comment